These emblems were found separately, the crook in
the Antechamber and the flail in the Treasury. The
flail is historically the more interesting because
it bears on the gold cap at the base of its
handle the king's name in its early form of Tutankhaton together with his throne name
Nebkheperura, thus showing that it had belonged to
him while he was still a child, but after he had
ascended the throne. Since a flail was one of the
symbols held by Egyptian kings in some of their
coronation ceremonies, it is at least possible that
this object was the actual flail used by Tutankhaton
in his coronation at Amarna when he was about
nine years of age and before he was crowned at
Karnak. The crook is inscribed on both the terminal
caps with the throne name only - a difference that,
in spite of the equality in size of the two objects,
may indicate that they were not originally made as a
pair. A second pair and an odd crook, all larger,
were found in the same wooden box as this flail. All
three crooks are composed of alternating cylindrical
sleeves of metal overlaid with gold and dark blue
glass upon a bronze core. The handle of the flail,
as far as the angular sleeve at the top, is
similarly composed, but the gilded beads in the
thongs of the swingle have wooden cores.
Although
the crook and the flail were most often represented
as emblems of the god
Osiris, they were also carried
on some ceremonial occasions, besides the
coronation, by the reigning pharaoh. Very
occasionally the crook was held by viceroys of Nubia
and also by viziers. A painted scene of tribute from
Asia in the tomb of Tutankhamun's viceroy of Nubia,
Huy, shows the king holding both the crook and flail
in his left hand and the sign for "life" (ankh) in
his right, while the viceroy holds a crook, but no
flail, in his left hand and a single ostrich plume
in his right. Only rarely is the flail shown in the
hands of priests or officials and such instances are
limited to scenes of royal jubilee festivals.
Notwithstanding these sporadic exceptions, the crook
and the flail were essentially Osirian emblems,
though possible not so in origin. Osiris is believed
to have acquired them from Andjeti, the local god of
a town in the Delta named Djedu, who was represented
in human form with two feathers on his head and
holding the crook and flail in his hands. At a very
early date in Egyptian history Osiris absorbed
Andjeti and adopted his insignia. Osiris, however,
was regarded not only as a god but also as a deified
deceased king and consequently his insignia,
particularly the crook and flail, were treated as
symbols of royalty.
It is not difficult to imagine how a shepherd's
crook could have acquired the symbolical
significance of rulership. Its name in Egyptian is
heqat and the most common word for "ruler" is
heqa. Not unnaturally it has been compared
with the crosier, the Christian pastoral staff. A
flail (called nekhakha), however, seems out
of character for a kindly and beneficent god like
Osiris and for this reason some authorities prefer
to regard it as a ladanisterion, a flail-like
instrument used until the present day by shepherds
in the Mediterranean region and elsewhere for
collecting ladanum, a gummy substance excreted from
the leaves of the Cistus plant. According to
classical writers, it was used in the preparation of
incense and unguents. This suggestion, proposed by
the late Professor P.E. Newberry who helped in the
clearance of Tutankhamun's tomb, is plausible, but,
as yet, there is no clear evidence that the
Cistus plant grew in Egypt in pharaonic times.