An interesting facet of ancient Egypt is that we are amazed by
what we see left form history, such as the pyramids and great
temples, but many scholars scoff at some legendary exploits.
One such tale, told to us in a tantalizingly brief
story by the Greek historian Herodotus, is of a sea voyage
that took place during the 26th Dynasty reign of
Necho
II. He
relates the circumnavigation of Africa some 2000 years before
the Portuguese mariners of Vasco da Gama.
We are not really given a reason for this expedition,
though it would seem that such voyages were made for economic
gain. Considering the control of the northern shores of the Mediterranean by the Greeks and of the southern coasts by the Phoenicians, the only region where Egypt, with its inferior fleet, might acquire some influence and wealth would have been eastern
Africa, where they had already established some trade.
However, it has also been suggested that the voyage might have
served a military purpose.
According to Herodotus,
Necho
II ordered a
Phoenician-crewed fleet to leave Egypt from the east by way of
the Gulf of Suez and to return via the Straits of Gibraltar at
the Mediterranean's western mouth. Hence, he expected this
expedition to navigate around Africa counterclockwise. This
would be a long journey, in which the crew would help support
themselves by establishing temporary settlements on land where
they would cultivate crops during the voyage.
According to the
story, after two full years the fleet eventually rounded the
Pillars of Hercules (the Straits of Gilbraltar), and returned
to Egypt during the course of the third year.
Herodotus
finishes the story with a surprising conclusion:
"the Phoenicians made a statement which I myself
do not believe (though others may if they wish) to the
effect that they sailed west around the southern end of
Africa, they had the sun on their right".
This is exactly what they would have seen going west around
the Cape of Good Hope at the southern tip of Africa, because
the sun appears to the right when traveling westward in the
southern hemisphere, but how could Herodotus
have known this
at such an early date if the journey did not take place.
Outside of Herodotus' account, there is little or no
evidence of such a voyage. However, most of his story appears
to at least be plausible, and it should be noted that this
voyage took place not so very distant from Herodotus' own
time. His Histories were written in about 440 BC, while
Necho
II came to the Egyptian throne in about 610 BC.
The
Egyptians would have known, for some time, a certain length of
Africa's east coast, for they had from earlier times been
making visits to the land
of Punt. Though Punt's exact location remains unknown, it
was almost certainly on Africa's east coast somewhat south of
Egypt. The Phoenicians had been in contact with the Atlantic since
the trading port of Gadir (modern Cadiz) was founded in about
800 BC. They also possessed ships that were capable of sailing
through the Straits of Gibraltar and along the North African
coast, so technically a trip around Africa would have been
possible. In fact, the winds and currents favor an east-west
circumnavigation of Africa, and navigation would have been no
problem if they kept the coast in sight. Furthermore, the
Egyptians had for many years undertook sea voyages to Byblos,
on the Levantine coast, and to Punt by way of the Red Sea.
Though the circumnavigation of Africa under Vasco da Gama, who
sailed from Lisbon in Portugal to Calicut in India, took only
ten months between 1497 and 1498, the two and a half year
journey of the Phoenician ships also seems reasonable,
especially considering their layover to replenish their
supplies.
The tale is also consistent with the foreign policy of Necho
II, who sought to benefit Egypt economically by
improving access to sea routes. He is credited with probably
starting the construction (or restoration) of a canal some 85
kilometers long and wide enough for sea going ships,
connecting the Nile Valley with the Red
Sea. This canal,
foreshadowing the modern Suez canal, later became an
internationally important trade route.
However, while many readers of Herodotus
have taken this
story for granted, it does not in fact prove that Necho
II's
fleet did circumnavigate Africa. It must be remembered that
Herodotus' Histories is an elaborate piece of rhetorical
writing, and is not an objective history, but rather a highly
literary, as well as partisan, analysis of the cultural clash
between the Greek and Persian cultures. He was a Greek who was
convinced of Greek superiority, and his favorite technique of
devaluing Persian achievements was to emphasize what other
non-Greeks (especially Egyptians) could achieve.
He also loved recounting stories of Egyptian kings solving
difficult problems, showing the depth of Egyptian wisdom,
which of course the Persians could not match.
Hence, because
we have no direct evidence of this journey around Africa from
contemporary Egyptian sources, it is likely that it never
took place. In fact, Egyptologist Alan Lloyd believes the
adventure extremely unlikely, stating that:
"If an Egyptian king, at any period, organized and dispatched an expedition, he did so for specific practical ends to meet specific practical needs. Disinterested inquiry or plain curiosity were always amongst the least evident of Egyptian habits of mind. What possible end could an Egyptian king have thought an enterprise of this sort might have served? To anyone familiar with Pharaonic ways of doing things the reply immediately prompted is an emphatic 'None at all!'. Given the context of Egyptian thought, economic life, and military interests, it is impossible for one to imagine what stimulus could have motivated Necho in such a scheme and if we cannot provide a reason which is sound within Egyptian terms of reference, then we have good reason to doubt the historicity of the entire episode."
Nevertheless, this story is a favorite of those who would
connect the culture, and specifically the pyramids of Mexico
with that of the Egyptians. They argue that ships could have
been separated from Necho's fleet, blown westward across the
Atlantic's narrowest part, ending up on the Brazilian cost.
From there, it would have been possible for them to sail north
to the Mexican Gulf, where they might have landed and
established a colony, spreading Egyptian culture throughout
Central and South America. However, this possibility is itself
once removed from a tale that must be questioned.
References:
| Title |
Author |
Date |
Publisher |
Reference Number |
|
Atlas of Ancient Egypt |
Baines, John; Malek, Jaromir |
1980 |
Les Livres De France |
None Stated |
|
Chronicle of the Pharaohs (The Reign-By-Reign Record of the Rulers and Dynasties of Ancient Egypt) |
Clayton, Peter A. |
1994 |
Thames and Hudson Ltd |
ISBN 0-500-05074-0 |
|
Dictionary of Ancient Egypt, The |
Shaw, Ian; Nicholson, Paul |
1995 |
Harry N. Abrams, Inc., Publishers |
ISBN 0-8109-3225-3 |
|
History of Ancient Egypt, A |
Grimal, Nicolas |
1988 |
Blackwell |
None Stated |
|
Monarchs of the Nile |
Dodson, Aidan |
1995 |
Rubicon Press |
ISBN 0-948695-20-x |
|
Oxford History of Ancient Egypt, The |
Shaw, Ian |
2000 |
Oxford University Press |
ISBN 0-19-815034-2 |
|
Seventy Great Mysteries of Ancient Egypt, The |
Manley, Bill (Editor) |
2003 |
Thames & Hudson Ltd |
ISBN 0-500-05123-2 |
Archives
|